This post makes me uncomfortable
Today is Blog Action Day. Tens of thousands of bloggers are writing posts on the topic of poverty. We’re supposed to write something that means something, that might make you think. But I’m stuck.
I was in Peace Corps in Mali, West Africa, when it was listed as the world’s second poorest country. My monthly living allowance was less than my home phone and cell phone bills, but I think my allowance was still more than what my Malian mother came across in a year.
My Malian mother never asked me for money. She brought me lunch every day — ground millet cooked into a large patty and topped with okra sauce — no meat, no vegetables. Each Saturday was market day, and I bought her a kilo of rice and a kilo of beans, which we would have on Sunday.
One day she came to my house with an empty can of instant coffee. “Kadiatou,” she said, calling me by my Malian name, “Do you have any coffee?” This was the first time she asked me for anything. I had just that very morning run out of my own supply of Nescafé coffee crystals, the only coffee we could really get. So I showed her my empty can — gave it to her, actually, since she and others liked to keep empty tins, old tuna cans, plastic containers.
“I’m sorry,” I said. “I really just ran out.”
It didn’t occur to me until an hour or two later that I could have given her money to buy coffee, that she probably needed it for a special occasion, that she was asking because she thought I would help. I really didn’t think about it. It didn’t cross my mind that she needed coffee and didn’t have any money to buy it. I had what I considered pocket change in my hut. She had nothing. And I didn’t even think to help.
What do I know of poverty? How can I understand the idea that there absolutely is no money to be had and no way to get it? In Mali, the mortality rate of kids under the age of 4 was 50 percent when I was there. When I arrived, one of my neighbors named their daughter Kadiatou after me. She was my namesake, my togoma, and she was sick all the time. And she had a 50/50 chance of living until the age of 4.
I’m sitting here in a fairly luxurious apartment in one of the most expensive cities in the US. I’ve been whining about not making enough money. Not making enough money for me means I can’t go to the coffee shop for Americanos every day. It means that I’m not going to buy a personalized license plate (I contemplated AVE Z). It doesn’t mean I can’t buy shoes when mine have holes. It doesn’t mean my children may die of malnutrition or illness.
When I was a kid, my parents really watched our money. My dad said he spent those years “investing in groceries.” We got blocks of processed cheese food and jars of peanut butter from the government. But we weren’t destitute. I can’t write about poverty. I can never understand what it means to be impoverished.
Another aspect of poverty that makes it difficult for me to grasp the concept is the enormity of the problem. Can one solve poverty? Can we alleviate that kind of suffering? Can we fix it? I feel overwhelmed into inaction. What could I possibly do to help? Give money to people on the street who say they’re poor? Help out overseas? You’ve heard the saying, “If you want to feed a man for a day, give him a fish. If you want to feed him for a lifetime, teach him how to fish.” But which people do we teach? And how do we teach them?
I’m embarrassed by this post. I’m embarrassed by my ignorance and my lack of initiative. I’m embarrassed by my relative wealth. And I just don’t know where to go from here. Do I rush out and start to help? Or perhaps I tackle another tremendous global disaster, like incurable cancer or the disappearing wetlands or drug addiction or child abuse or female circumcision or….
Or do I just keep writing here in my little apartment with my cat and my recycle bins and hope those real problems never affect me?
Hmm. Not sure they’ll ask me to participate in Blog Action Day 2009.



Beth on 14 Oct 2008 at 10:31 pm #
Be sure to check out the conversations about poverty from the Blog Action Day website.
Copyblogger just wrote a very inspirational post and offered to donate $25 each time someone donates at least $10 to Save the Children.
Great job, Brian.
http://www.copyblogger.com/vicious-cycle-of-poverty/
Renato Sogueco on 15 Oct 2008 at 6:22 am #
Thanks for sharing your story. I think this is a great contribution for Blog Action Day 2008 Poverty. As you say, poverty is an uncomfortable thing, but it’s something we all must address by getting out of our comfort zone.
banquet manager on 15 Oct 2008 at 8:31 am #
Thanks for stopping by my blog and leaving a comment.
So You Want To Be a Banquet Manager
Sarah on 15 Oct 2008 at 12:00 pm #
I am a teacher and most of my students are considered poor. Who knows how we can solve all the problems – there are so many and they are overwhelming.
I can just remember the story about the person on the beach throwing in starfish who were stranded on the shore. Another person went up to the person throwing starfish back into the ocean and asked how that could make a difference – there were thousands of starfish who were going to die, stranded on the beach. The person just continued throwing them in and said “I just made a difference for that one, and that one, and that one….
We do what we can – it will make a difference.
Silverstar98121 on 15 Oct 2008 at 12:49 pm #
I am considered impoverished in this country. I live on Social Security Disability. But I have a roof over my head, and enough food. I am a lot richer than a lot of the people who live in my public housing building. I know people who are squatters, like my boyfriend who lives at the building he is remodeling. I know people who live on the street. One of them just lost his van, and it’s getting cold outside. People sleep in doorways in my neighborhood. And yet, when we think of how other people live in other countries, even they are rich. How do we solve it? Don’t know. But I have extra blankets in my cedar chest that I think may be going out on the street where they can do some good. I guess we just throw starfish.
10/16/2008 Writing Jobs and Links » PoeWar on 15 Oct 2008 at 10:03 pm #
[...] This post makes me uncomfortable — lifeonavenuez.com [...]
Craig on 16 Oct 2008 at 3:49 am #
Begin Snarky — I am completely and totally against poverty in my household — End Snarky
There you go. How did I do? (He asks while semi-cowering)
Craig
Lisa Claydon on 16 Oct 2008 at 5:31 am #
Thank you for sharing. I spent a few weeks in South America in the late 80s. I felt out of sorts when I came back to the US because we have SO much…and we take it all for granted. Most Americans have no concept of poverty. Teens are worried about getting the latest iPods and jeans. The big question is how do we get people to understand and care?
Rebecca Smith on 21 Oct 2008 at 10:57 am #
Wow, Beth. Intense stuff. Very well written.
Have you read “Monique and the Mango Rains: Two Years with a Midwife in Mali”? It’s written by the wife of a colleague of mine. She was also in the Peace Corps in Mali. Based on your experience, I think you’d like it very much.